(Originally Posted July 2018)
Well, that’ll teach me to ever be optimistic about a WWE show again…
So Extreme Rules has been and gone, and while there was some stuff to like, there was a whole bunch of stuff to hate as well, so let’s just get straight to it and rank every match from Extreme Rules 2018 from worst to best.
12 – Dolph Ziggler(c) def. Seth Rollins
(Intercontinental Championship)
(30 Minute Iron Man)

Screw everything about this match.
I’m writing this section straight after the match finished, because I want to capture the emotion I’m feeling right now. I was so excited when I saw that this was going to be the main event, I thought it was a sure-fire match of the year contender and we’d all be in for a treat. But that was simply an exercise in proving just how wrong it’s possible for a man to be.
First of all, if you were in that crowd, fuck you. You didn’t even give the match a chance before crapping all over it, you found your one joke that you all thought was hilarious (and I promise you, you were the only ones) and just drilled it into the ground not even paying attention to the match; AND THEN you have the audacity to be upset when it ends in a draw, so fuck you.
Then the match itself, which was pure disappointment from start to finish. Seth pulling out two falls less than ten minutes in made no sense when we’ve seen both men go through far worse beatings. I thought Drew running in and beating down Seth would add quite a good story element for the match if it had any bearing on the match long-term, which it didn’t. Sure, it allowed Ziggler to equalise, but I really don’t see how the last 20 minutes of the match would’ve been any different if we had gone into it 0-0 instead of 3-3.
Instead, after the first ten minutes, in which six out of the eight falls in this match took place, the two men proceeded to put on a back and forth match that was….fine I guess? It wasn’t terrible but it’s utter shit compared to what we’ve already seen these two do over the past month.
Then of course. the match ends in a draw and Kurt Angle comes out simply to get a hometown pop and restart the thing, only for it to end again two seconds later, when Ziggler pins Rollins thanks to Drew popping up again, and I honestly couldn’t be more furious and disappointed right now.
I’m writing this last paragraph the next day, and looking back I feel that, while it wasn’t a terrible match, the combination of the crowd, lazy storytelling and ok, but not great, action all combined to make a rather horrible watching experience, so I stand by my decision to place it last.
11 – Carmella(c) def. Asuka
(Smackdown Women’s Championship)

Ok, so I ranked Rollins vs Ziggler last because it was the one I least enjoyed watching, but if I were ranking these matches purely on the wrestling, this would be last.
I was very tempted to just put a picture of James Ellsworth as the header for this section, because that’s all that really mattered in this match. Less than 30 seconds in he was getting involved by just throwing stuff down to Carmella; which seems like a fatal flaw of the whole Shark Cage concept, why not just put the cage at the top of the ramp instead of directly above the ring?
The two women would then put on the most basic of matches, before we got to all that Vince McMahon really cared about seeing in this match it seems. So yes, in a move that – to quote Corey Graves – “Even Stevie Wonder saw coming” Ellsworth was able to escape from the shark cage, except in true Ellsworth fashion, he fucks it up and leaves himself hanging upside-down from the cage. At which point Asuka smiles with glee and starts batting him about like a pinata, but this distraction allowed Carmella to regain her bearings and, say it with me now, score another dirty win over Asuka.
Remember when Asuka first debuted and we were worried they were going to treat her as just another woman? Then they gave us false hope with the Royal Rumble and Wrestlemania, and since then she’s been nothing but another cog in the machine; and while Carmella’s heelish wins are getting her good heat and serving her well, it’s starting to wear thin, and I really hope we can get this over with soon.
10 – Finn Balor def. Baron Corbin

Apparently Finn Balor was the first ever Universal Champion.
Well, that’s all commentary seemed to want to talk about anyway, probably because it’s a darn slight more interesting than whatever Balor’s stuck doing nowadays. This match was perfectly passable, I found myself getting into it a bit in the middle, but that illusion was soon shattered thanks to the finish; where we all got to tick another box off our bingo cards as Balor rolled Corbin up for a *cough* “surprise” win.
Not really much else to say, I’ve no doubt Corbin will get his win back on Raw tonight anyway.
9 – The B-Team def. Matt Hardy and Bray Wyatt(c)
(Raw Tag Team Championships)

So, The Authors of Pain are winning those titles VERY soon.
Don’t get me wrong, I loved this surprise win, but if you think the B-Team are anything other than transitional champions, you’re in for a rude awakening.
After WWE failed to capitalize on the popularity of things like The Fashion Police and Rusev Day, we were all pretty certain the B-Team was going to be another one of those stories; but once in a while, if the wind’s blowing in the right direction, WWE go for it. However, I can’t say I’m fully behind this one, because while it created a great moment, I think it might do more harm than good in the long run.
First off, think about how much this damages Matt and Bray. They could’ve been so unbelievably over with those titles, but instead they didn’t do anything for a couple of months and then lost them to a team whose name is a joke about how crap they are. Also I feel like AOP would benefit more from squashing a team who actually seemed like a threat, instead of two guys who we know don’t stand a chance anyway.
But all of that is a little way away, for now, let’s just enjoy the moment.
8 – Bobby Lashley def. Roman Reigns

You know what? This was a lot less crap than I was anticipating.
I mean, don’t get me wrong, it was by no means world-class and when it came to the result I still couldn’t care less, but I actually found myself quite into this one. It didn’t quite have the urgency I would’ve liked to see from these two, but from about the halfway mark, I found the match quite compelling.
In my predictions I was certain of a Roman Reigns win, but this match did a very good job of making me doubt that fact, before finally smashing it with Lashley pinning Reigns, with a Spear no less.
Once again though, I’m sad to say I can’t be pleased by this result, because this means we’re getting Lashley vs Lesnar at Summerslam, and unless Strowman gets involved, Lesnar is walking away with that title still over his shoulder.
7 – Andrade “Cien” Almas def. Sin Cara

Tranquilo.
I so hope they keep building Almas up like this, the man has all the makings to be one my favourite wrestlers ever, I just hope they don’t treat him like they did Bobby Roode. That said, this was certainly a great start. While I’d rather it wasn’t on the pre-show, it doesn’t matter too much in this instance. It was just a solid match with a couple of impressive spots, all designed to make Almas look good, so please keep this up WWE, and you’ll have another shining star on your hands.
6 – SAnitY def. The New Day
(Tables Match)

Given that this show ended up running 15 minutes short, this really should’ve been on the main card.
Regardless, this was a really fun match with a lot to love. I really hope this isn’t the last match we see between these two because I think they could work magic if given the right build and enough time.
Tables matches can often seem a bit boring thanks to how contrived it can be for wrestlers to have to set up tables and put them in specific places so you know what’s going to happen; but they were able to avoid that in this match. Having 6 men allowed things to be set up while others kept the flow going in the ring, and it meant that the match didn’t have to stop at any point, which gets around a big issue with these types of matches.
However the main focus of this match, is holy crap how much money is Killian Dain going to make in his career? Even if SAnitY as a faction falls flat on its face, Killian Dain is going to have a very successful career, a 300 pound man who moves like he’s 200 and can seemingly do just about anything.
5 – Alexa Bliss(c) def. Nia Jax
(Raw Women’s Championship)
(Extreme Rules)

Ok, so this match was pretty light on surprises, but overall, I had a pretty good time watching this match.
I’m not entirely sure why Natalya was there, pretty much just an excuse for Ronda to get involved because she just can’t take seeing her friend get beat up or something. That aside, the action here was fast and pretty fun to watch. I feel like they could’ve used the Extreme Rules stipulation a little bit better, instead of just as an excuse for everyone to get involved; not to mention that Nia just seemed to disappear once Ronda jumped into the mix.
All that said, I had fun watching this, and this seems like as good a set up as any for a triple threat feud at Summerslam between Nia, Ronda and Alexa.
4 – The Bludgeon Brothers(c) def. Team Hell No
(Smackdown Tag Team Championships)

I know Daniel Bryan is really good at the whole underdog thing, but WWE know that’s not all he can do right?
Either way this was still a great match, taking out Kane before the start of the match was a great idea, and although it did leave the door open for someone to replace him, I think having Bryan still try and go it alone was a good decision.
I don’t really need to explain just how good Bryan is at playing the plucky underdog role when facing two behemoths like the Bludgeon Brothers, because you all already know that; and this was certainly a great version of that formula. I think the match could’ve done with a couple of extra minutes at the end, maybe give Bryan one more spot where it looks like he was about to win before being destroyed just to get the drama to an extreme high; but even without that, this was still a great match.
3 – Kevin Owens def. Braun Strowman
(Steel Cage)

If you’ve been reading my articles on wrestling for a while now, you’ll know that some of my favourite matches from shows, are ones that take a simple story, and tell it effectively; and that’s exactly what this match did.
The story was simple, Strowman wants to destroy Owens, Owens wants to part of it, and the steel cage is there to ensure Owens can’t run away easily. I think that this was one of the few circumstances in which a Steel Cage was able to add to the story of the match, since it legitimately made sense that the point was to escape the cage, because that’s exactly what Owens wanted to do.
Aside from that, watching Strowman do what he does best is always a joy, and Owens played his role perfectly and did a very good job of staying true to his character. He acts cowardly and tries to flee at the first opportunity, but the moment he’s able to fluke an advantage, he just can’t help but flaunt it. When Owens knocked Strowman down the first time, it would’ve absolutely been easy for Owens to sprint out the door and win, but he just couldn’t help himself from trying to get the pin instead; then later when he gets the handcuffs, suddenly he switches from total coward, to a boasting asshole that can’t get enough of himself.
Naturally this costs Owens eventually as Strowman is no mere mortal, all it takes is one good yank and the handcuffs shatter just as Owens reaches the top of the cage. At which point Strowman sees red and decides that the only sensible thing to do is throw Owens from the top of the cage, through the announce tables. This finish was brilliant, as it does allow Owens to say he beat Strowman, but it makes Strowman look like an absolute God of wrestling as he stands on top of a cage with his arms in the air with an unconscious Owens at his feet.
2 – Shinsuke Nakamura def. Jeff Hardy(c)
(United States Championship)

I wanted to put this at number one, but it didn’t seem fair considering it was a 5 second match.
I talked in my predictions about how Nakamura needed a good win here to get back all the credibility he’d lost since Wrestlemania, and this match did that and more. With a low blow before the match and a Kinshasa immediately following, Nakamura winning the US title in this fashion puts him right back up in the position he should be right now.
However that wasn’t all, as immediately following the match, none other than Mr RKO himself showed up to stick his nose in things. However, instead of doling out RKO’s to everything in sight, he simply dragged Jeff Hardy to the centre of the ring and stamped on his balls so hard, he may never be able to speak in a low pitch again.
I don’t really know how good a Orton vs Nakamura match is going to be, but the feud is certainly off to a great start.
1 – AJ Styles(c) def. Rusev
(WWE Championship)

How hard is it to get the world championship match as the main event?
That gripe aside, I really enjoyed this match, Styles can get a good match out of anybody, and Rusev can really turn it up when he needs to. While I was worried Rusev would be a bit too much of a heel in this match, I feel they did a good job of playing off the fact that the crowd really wanted Rusev to win here to create a very compelling match, and while I never believed Styles was losing that title, I definitely doubted myself a couple of times towards the end.
The only major negative is Aiden English’s presence at ringside, when he distracted Styles at the start, that was good enough, but other than that he didn’t really do much of any value. Sure, he technically helped Rusev escape the Calf-Crusher, but that rope was well within Rusev’s reach anyway, and the moment English removed that turnbuckle pad, it was obvious that Rusev was going to go into it.
However, I don’t think that took away from the match that much and it actually left the window open a little for Rusev to maybe comeback into things in the future; since he couldn’t lock the accolade in thanks to an injured leg, it leaves that door open to say that maybe Rusev could beat Styles if he locks the accolade in properly.
I really had a great time with this match, and if it were the main event of the evening, I probably would’ve thought much higher of this show in general, but oh well, onto Summerslam I guess.
Well there you go! That was my thoughts on every match from Extreme Rules 2018, and looking back on it now, it wasn’t bad as I initially felt it was, although it wasn’t anything that special, but hopefully Summerslam will be an event to remember.
As always please share this around and follow me on Twitter @10ryawoo, and make sure you comeback this weekend for another Triple Threat Review!

































